Subscribe to Holyrood updates

Newsletter sign-up


Follow us

Scotland’s fortnightly political & current affairs magazine


Subscribe to Holyrood
by Sofia Villegas
17 January 2024
Data strategy lacks ambition, transport inquiry hears

Westminster retains reserved powers for ‘national’ transport | Alamy

Data strategy lacks ambition, transport inquiry hears

The transport data strategy is a "foundational" paper rather than an "ambitious" or "highly refined one”, MPs have heard during the first session of the future of transport data inquiry.  

Professor Susan Grant-Muller, chair in Technologies and Informatics at the Institute for Transport Studies said: “We need that boldness to be able to step forward and to look at data in quite an ambitious way to gain that overall integrated picture of what’s happening and how we can better prepare the transport system for the future”.  

The decentralised approach to data collection, ownership and handling is hindering the transport system's future potential, witnesses told the transport committee during the meeting.  

Grant-Muller called for more “cross government-department thinking and leadership” from the Department for Transport (DfT).   

Doing so would allow for the strategy to “look sideways into other sectors”, so data collected for other reasons is of sufficient quality for other purposes, such as improving the transport sector, she explained.  

She also highlighted data on demographics as a "clear" and "huge gap" and coined it as “the big piece of the jigsaw" which would allow for more "tailored" services.  

David McArthur, associate director of the Urban Big Data Centre at the University of Glasgow, who attended as a virtual witness, said that the fragmentation of data ownership between operators and other firms including Google, is a significant barrier. He explained this had led to “little pots of data” covering the same thing, making it difficult to form a unified strategy.    

McArthur also highlighted that local authorities may not have the computing infrastructure needed, especially for “newer forms of data”.   

Other barriers were named as contributing factors to the lack of necessary skills across the sector and the “culture of fear” around data sharing.  

When asked how to update regulations to allow for the maximum amount of data to be shared, Grant-Muller suggested "the public good test". In other words, there should be access to data if it is for the public good.  

The transport data strategy policy paper was released last March, and it outlined how the DfT would work with the transport sector to use data “to help grow and level up the economy, reduce environmental impacts and improve transport for the user.” 

In June, the Transport Committee launched the future of transport data inquiry following proposals from experts and academics to MPs on what to investigate next.  

Holyrood Newsletters

Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe

Read the most recent article written by Sofia Villegas - TikTok fined £1.8m after providing Ofcom with inaccurate information.

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox


Popular reads
Back to top