Menu
Subscribe to Holyrood updates

Newsletter sign-up

Subscribe

Follow us

Scotland’s fortnightly political & current affairs magazine

Subscribe

Subscribe to Holyrood
by Chris Marshall
20 November 2026
Writing in the margins: The political extremes of poet Hugh MacDiarmid

Hugh MacDiarmid stood for the Communist Party at the 1964 general election | Alamy

Writing in the margins: The political extremes of poet Hugh MacDiarmid

In 2015, weeks after a historic general election result in which they won 56 out of Scotland’s 59 constituencies, SNP MPs wore white roses for the state opening of parliament. A photo from that time, which would later become an internet meme, shows Alex Salmond striding gleefully through the corridors of power, arms swinging, a flower fixed to his lapel.

Long associated with Jacobitism and attempts to reinstall the Stuart dynasty in the eighteenth century, the white rose had been worn by Salmond before, notably as he pledged his oath of allegiance to the Scottish people following the reopening of the Scottish Parliament in 1999. For the SNP and its former leader, however, the symbol’s adoption was for its association not with Bonnie Prince Charlie but Hugh MacDiarmid, the nationalist poet whose quatrain, The Little White Rose, is inscribed on a block of blonde sandstone set into Holyrood’s Canongate Wall. 

The rose of all the world is not for me
I want for my part
Only the little white rose of Scotland
That smells sharp and sweet
– and breaks the heart.

MacDiarmid’s political legacy is as complicated as the man himself. Born Christopher Murray Grieve in the Dumfriesshire town of Langholm at the end of the nineteenth century, he began writing under his pen name in the early 1920s. A lifelong Marxist as well as Scottish nationalist (two otherwise divergent impulses) he also expressed a fleeting admiration for the Italian fascist Benito Mussolini. This weekend, a special conference will assess that complex legacy on the centenary of the publication of MacDiarmid’s most famous poem, A Drunk Man Looks at the Thistle.

Running to 2,685 lines in length, the poem is a modernist epic in the same mould as James Joyce’s 1922 novel Ulysses, itself a major influence on MacDiarmid. It’s also a political manifesto of sorts for MacDiarmid, once pithily described as more Jacobin than Jacobite, and certainly no centrist, who wrote he’d “aye be whaur / Extremes meet”. Lively and freewheeling if at times also difficult and abstruse, the poem is written in MacDiarmid’s ‘synthetic Scots’, which drew heavily on the dialect of Lowland Scotland. 

“In my reading, it is the single most spectacular poem in all of the twentieth century,” says Alexander Linklater, author of an upcoming biography and one of the organisers of the conference. “I don’t think there is any other piece of poetry that achieves the extraordinary pyrotechnic effects that MacDiarmid can achieve in his Scots – they have a spinetingling quality to them.

“Having said that, it is in many ways a difficult poem and that’s one of the challenges we face talking about it. Overall, it’s structurally messy – dare I say it could have done with a bit more editing.” 

As well as the eponymous thistle, MacDiarmid’s poem also makes reference to the works of Robert Burns (“no wan in fifty kens a wurd Burns wrote”) as well as contemporaries including Alexander Blok and TS Eliot, whose own masterpiece The Wasteland had been published just four years earlier and who had provocatively asked if there even was such a thing as Scottish literature in a 1919 essay. MacDiarmid playfully suggests that had the English poet come to Scotland, “he wad ha’e written / A better poem syne (then) – like this, by gum!” 

MacDiarmid’s prickliness made it hard for him to reconcile with any one political party. While he would eventually be enthusiastically adopted by the SNP, he had previously enjoyed a fractious relationship with the campaign for Scottish self-determination, having helped establish the National Party of Scotland (a precursor to the SNP) before being expelled for his Marxist-Leninist views. He later stood for the SNP in Glasgow Kelvingrove in the 1945 and 1950 general elections, failing to get elected on both occasions, and then for the Communist Party of Great Britain in 1964. In 1949, he appeared alongside Charlie Chaplin, JB Priestley and the historian EH Carr on a list of communist sympathisers or “those who should not be trusted” compiled by George Orwell and later handed to the Foreign Office. 

MacDiarmid, who listed “Anglophobia” among his interests in his Who’s Who entry, was, according to Linklater, an “extremist in all things”. He believed in Scottish independence at a time, the 1920s, when others were campaigning for home rule, then a radical notion in its own right. The year after Mussolini came to power in Italy in 1922, MacDiarmid wrote A Plea for Scottish Fascism and a Programme for Scottish Fascism, advocating what has been called a “fascism of the left” as a vehicle towards independence. But any brief attraction towards fascist ideas appears to have long since passed by the time of Hitler’s rise to power and the Spanish civil war during the following decade. Confronted with his contradictions, MacDiarmid would quote the great American poet Walt Whitman, saying: “I contain multitudes”.

“MacDiarmid was a great supporter of Irish independence,” Linklater says. “But the Irish Free State was not a fully independent state, so there wasn’t even the Irish model in the 1920s. MacDiarmid was, at that stage, arguing for full independence [for Scotland]… he was right on the vanguard, pretty much alone, which is why years later [the poet] Norman McCaig would refer to him as a ‘torchlight procession of one’. 

“He had a multitude of ridiculous and sometimes obscene political opinions… they were such a dolly mixture of crackpot ideas that it’s quite hard to take him seriously with any of them.” 

It is for a reassessment of those ideas – and of course MacDiarmid’s work as a poet – which historians, writers, and even members of MacDiarmid’s family will gather at Glasgow’s Royal Concert Hall on Saturday. Hosted in partnership with the Saltire Society, the National Library of Scotland, the Centre for Scottish & Celtic Studies and Edinburgh Napier University, the conference plans to extend its focus beyond MacDiarmid’s best-known poem to his role in the so-called Scottish Renaissance, his invention of synthetic Scots as a national language and his influence on ideas of Scottish national identity. Perhaps unsurprisingly, MacDiarmid continues to divide opinion long after his death.

Historian Tom Devine says MacDiarmid’s poetry first appeared in a Scotland which was still recovering from the shock of the First World War and amid rising levels of unemployment and a population falling due to the huge numbers emigrating overseas in search of a better life. 

“There was an atmosphere of gloom, an atmosphere of loathing in this country over that period,” he says. “There was a sense of the end of Scotland. There are actually pamphlets written with that title and titles like The Eclipse of Scotland. Many commentators thought it was the end of Scotland as a separate identity, a separate nationhood.”

Devine says MacDiarmid’s belief in Scottish independence at that time was “one part of his craziness” and “utterly untypical” of what was of interest to the rest of the nation politically.

“In a serious way, that was never on the agenda at that time. The SNP, which was created through the fusion of two other nationalist parties, was almost entirely political irrelevant in that period and would continue to be so until after the Second World War. 

“What gave force to political contests and elections was nothing to do with [Scottish] nationalism at all because the conventional wisdom was that Scotland could not possibly go alone.”

In the 1930s, MacDiarmid returned to writing poems in English, works such as Stony Limits and Second Hymn to Lenin. He also moved his young family to the island of Whalsay in Shetland, eking out a meagre existence in a former crofter’s cottage while enjoying one of his most productive periods as a poet. During the war, he moved to Glasgow after being conscripted to work as an engineer on the Clyde, a job he appeared entirely unsuited to. In the 1972 BBC documentary Rebel Poet, MacDiarmid’s former foreman remembered him as someone who had “no experience of heavy work at all”. “After all, he was a man of letters, a writer… as a man of his journalistic abilities, it was amazing his potentiality wasn’t put to better use”. 

It was not just in the war effort that MacDiarmid was difficult to pigeonhole – in truth, he would remain a contrarian for the rest of life until his death aged 86 in 1978 at his cottage Brownsbank near Biggar. The following year, a majority of Scots voted in favour of establishing a Scottish parliament but in numbers that fell short of the threshold (40 per cent of the electorate) required to turn the result into law. It would be another 20 years before the devolved assembly came into being and an almost a decade after that before the SNP came to power. 

By that time, MacDiarmid, who once referred to the SNP as a “gang of philistines”, had been well and truly coopted by the party despite having had a fraught relationship with it when he was alive. As well as regularly wearing a white rose, Salmond, a lover of Scottish poetry more generally, recited The Little White Rose alongside lines from Burns during the eulogy he gave at the funeral of SNP trailblazer Winnie Ewing in 2023, someone who had known MacDiarmid personally when he was alive.

But despite the huge outpouring of support for Yes during the 2014 independence referendum from the country’s artists, writers and musicians, contemporary Scotland can feel like a culturally bereft place at times.

“I think [MacDiarmid] would regard today’s SNP as a culture-free zone,” says Linklater. “His relevance [to the party] is really one of historical memory. For MacDiarmid, Scottish culture was about poetry; he thought there was a poetry to Scotland that was one of the great achievements of the world. He was a Scottish exceptionalist. One of the curiosities of contemporary nationalism is that is plays that exceptionalism down [and argues] we’re just another small, social-democratic country.”

MacDiarmid, in particular, has largely disappeared from the culture, his work little-known among the population at large, although his poetry is still part of the national curriculum, with the poem The Bonnie Broukit Bairn (1925) appearing in recent Higher English exams. While his literary significance is clear, his political influence on modern nationalism is perhaps less obvious.

Linklater, however, disagrees, crediting the poet with helping to pioneer a nationalism of the left which has become the defining ideology of the SNP during the devolution era. 

“In the 1920s and 30s, MacDiarmid was a communist and a nationalist when you could not be a communist and a nationalist. So the idea there was such a thing as a leftwing nationalism was an innovation of MacDiarmid. By the time you get to the Nicola Sturgeon-era SNP, all young nationalists think they are leftwing. But that is actually an innovation of the last 30 or 40 years, and MacDiarmid was its pioneer.” 

Holyrood Newsletters

Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox

Subscribe

Popular reads
Back to top