EHRC chair: Fear is being stoked on single-sex code
After a morning of high emotion, Dr Mary-Ann Stephenson moved to provide calm.
The chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) was giving evidence on her organisation’s code of practice for services and associations.
A 300-odd page document, it replaced 2011-era rules on the provision of services after the Supreme Court ruled that ‘sex’ in the Equality Act means biology, not gender.
The guide is supposed to help organisations stay on the right side of the law and prevent discrimination.
Last week MSPs on the Equalities, Civil Justice and Human Rights Committee heard it had brought “clarity” for leisure services, police, the NHS and more.
This week a fresh set of witnesses representing LGBT charities said it had instead created “fear”, with Florence Oulds of Scottish Trans saying a “general feeling of loss, misery and despair” now pervades the community.
“For many people, it feels so crushing and difficult at the moment, and so incredibly hard when it feels like we've had so many losses as a community over the past few years and a significant regression in rights,” Oulds said, appearing alongside Equality Network colleague Vic Valentine and Dr Mhairi Crawford, chief executive of LGBT Youth Scotland.
It is “hard not to feel like” the EHRC has come down on “one side” of issues around sex, gender and identity, Oulds suggested, “because it shows no real interest in helping services, public functions, and associations include trans people, or addressing the significant issue of our exclusion if that is what must be done”. “It feels like our equality regulator, who's supposed to be looking out for our human rights, is very much not looking out for their human rights,” came the conclusion.
Crawford also spoke of a sense of fear amongst the 13-25-year-olds her charity works with, saying some were “losing hope for the future”, while Valentine suggested that imprisoning trans women offenders in men’s jails could lead to suicides.
“The policy that we now have to house all prisoners on estates for their sex at birth is how we used to make decisions about trans prisoners in the past across the UK, and a large reason that was changed was due to the deaths of four trans women by suicide across 2015 and 2016,” Valentine said. “We've been here before, this is how we treated trans people when we placed them in prisons before, and the results were pretty stark – as stark as they can be.”
Crawford had anecdotal evidence to back that up: a 24-year-old trans person had said that imprisonment in a men’s jail would be like a “death sentence”, and so now was scared to speak to police.
MSPs also heard that directions to treat patients according to their biology had led to trans people declining to seek medical help, even against advice from clinicians. “Can implementing the code be done in a way that does not result in harm, inequality, discrimination, and human rights breaches? I simply don't think that it can be,” Valentine said.
There were further stories of real-life experience, with Oulds speaking of a trans person who had been told there were no suitable facilities in their preferred leisure centre. Was that a private or public facility, Claire Baker MSP wondered. Oulds did not know.
“I know it can't be easy talking about the subject, and I hear the kind of pain that you have to go through in telling those stories,” Green MSP Holly Bruce told the panel.
it's incumbent on all of us to try and take the temperature down
Speaking afterwards, Stephenson was also concerned about fear – specifically discussion of the code which has “served to really stoke people’s fears about things which are unlikely to happen or should not be happening”.
“The code has been characterised and talked about in really kind of inflated language, saying that it excludes all trans people from public life, that there's going to be genital checks to ensure people's access to services, all of this sort of stuff.
“I can understand feelings are running high, people are upset, but actually, it doesn't help. What it does is create more anxiety among people about things that actually the law doesn't say, the code doesn't say, and I think I think it's incumbent on all of us to try and take the temperature down a little bit in this area and to try to recognise that at the heart of the Equality Act is trying to build a society where everybody is able to live with dignity and have access to the services they need, not to face discrimination and so on.
“Obviously, within that, that includes treating some people differently in some circumstances, and that is legitimate. It needs to be done in a way that ensures other people still have access to services, and we need to work through how to do that. Sometimes it's straightforward. Sometimes it's a bit more complex. As we heard in terms of health, obviously clinical needs will always come first, and that would come before, for example, any sort of single-sex service in the NHS if there's an emergency, for example. But I think we need to be able to talk about this in a way that is respectful and calm, and recognises that there are multiple people in these situations who have rights. And sometimes people want incompatible things and we have to work out how best to get there.
“What we've done in the code to set out what the Supreme Court ruled on the Equality Act is to say ‘this is where the law is now in terms of how these rights are balanced’.”
Holyrood Newsletters
Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe