Menu
Subscribe to Holyrood updates

Newsletter sign-up

Subscribe

Follow us

Scotland’s fortnightly political & current affairs magazine

Subscribe

Subscribe to Holyrood
by Louise Wilson
19 November 2026
‘Who knew what and when’: Michael Marra demands answers after allegations of avoidable deaths at Aberdeen hospital

Michael Marra raised the issues at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary during FMQs | Alamy

‘Who knew what and when’: Michael Marra demands answers after allegations of avoidable deaths at Aberdeen hospital

Scottish Government ministers must make clear what they knew and when after allegations of avoidable deaths at an Aberdeen hospital surfaced, Scottish Labour has demanded.

Leader Michael Marra has also urged the lord advocate to consider criminal prosecution, after a whistleblower from Aberdeen Royal Infirmary (ARI) called for a corporate homicide investigation.

Dr Mohammed Habib, a surgeon at the hospital, said he has been raising concerns about patient safety over a number of years – including writing directly to the first minister.

Marra, raising the matter during FMQs, said that “nothing was done” despite Habib’s efforts, and that families “deserve answers”.

First Minister John Swinney pointed to changes to the leadership team at NHS Grampian, the health board in charge of ARI, as evidence of government action after various concerns were raised.

The allegations come just a week after a critical Healthcare Improvement Scotland report on NHS Grampian. It concluded that there were “very serious shortcomings” with the board’s leadership and oversight of clinical governance, which led to failures in learning from adverse events.

Marra said: “The first minister was told not once but three times, and the health board buried the evidence. Enough is enough. The permanent secretary must commission an urgent internal review on who knew what and when within the Scottish Government.

“The lord advocate must move now, today, towards a criminal prosecution. Hundreds of grieving families across the country will be wondering today, this afternoon, if it was their son, their daughter, their mum or dad who died needlessly and who might still be with them – if only the government has listened. They deserve answers and they deserve justice.

“The first minister was told and did nothing. He must act today to get the answers for these families.”

Habib said he had formally reported dozens of avoidable deaths since 2021, including to police. No charges were brought. He also leaked an unpublished expert review, commissioned by the health board, from 2022 which found 19 avoidable deaths in liver and pancreatic surgery.

Swinney said that correspondence received by ministers was given an “appropriate” response to ensure “necessary action is being pursued”. That included, he said, advice on what evidence could be handed to police and what support was available through the national whistleblowing service.

On wider issues at the health board, the first minister said the government had set out its “dissatisfaction with the conduct of NHS Grampian”.

He added: “It is NHS Grampian’s responsibility to ensure that the performance of its clinicians and the delivery of services are undertaken in accordance with the expectations of the approach set by the government in relation to patient safety.

“Now, the actions that have been taken in relation to the changes in the leadership in NHS Grampian have been undertaken to ensure that the government can be confident about the standard of care that I would place on NHS Grampian. That is where we have to ensure that the necessary changes have been made.”

Regarding the question of criminal prosecution, he said it would be “wrong” for him to intervene. “It is for the police to consider any evidence and for the lord advocate and the Crown to make any judgements about the merits of criminal prosecution,” he said.

The whistleblowing by Habib was also raised by Scottish Greens co-leader Gillian Mackay and Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay.

Mackay said that many patients will be feeling “anxiety” about the news and “potentially thinking twice about attending hospitals for planned or unscheduled care”. She asked: “What will the government to do ensure that those patients can access safe healthcare that they can have confidence in?”

Findlay said the issues were a result of wider “cultural” problems within the public sector, with bosses “protected and promoted”. “This rotten culture has been imposed by this rotten SNP government; it contaminated Scotland’s public bodies,” he added.

Swinney again pointed to leadership changes within the health board as a result of government intervention, saying this should inspire confidence in patients.

NHS Grampian has been contacted for comment.

Holyrood Newsletters

Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe

Categories

Health

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox

Subscribe

Popular reads
Back to top