John Swiney warns of ‘significant financial implications’ of Milburn review
The Scottish Government will “consider carefully” a report on reducing the number of young people not in education, employment or training (Neets) but many of the recommendations are already “embedded” in its approach, John Swinney has said.
Responding to a question during backbench FMQs on Tuesday afternoon, the first minister said the Milburn review was a “substantial contribution to the debate” around Neets.
But he said a number of the recommendations made in the report were about delivering the approach already being taken in Scotland into England, such as a renewed focus on vocational qualifications.
He also warned that changes to the welfare system could be some “significant financial implications” to his government.
The UK Government has pledged to build a “whole new system for young people” to help them get into work.
Speaking in the House of Commons on Tuesday following the publication of the report, work and pensions secretary Pat McFadden said that the crisis of almost one million Neets in the UK “creates a human cost that no country should ask its young people to bear”.
“It robs them of the thing that is most important to their lives: the prospect of a good future, and it demands a response that is much more than a conventional departmental response,” he told MPs.
McFadden was flanked by Prime Minister Andy Burnham and Chancellor John Healey as he delivered the government’s response to the highly anticipated report, which warned that Britain “is at risk of losing a generation of young people”.
Burnham has made getting more young people into work a major part of his political agenda. Currently, almost a million 16-to-24-year-olds in the UK are Neets, equivalent to around 13 per cent of the demographic.
Speaking in a press conference this morning, Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, described the Neet situation as a "moral crisis" facing the country.
Milburn set out “a 10-year project” to address the crisis with the aim of reducing the Neet rate to around five per cent by 2036, which he calls “an effective rate of Neet Zero”.
The report, which runs to 278 pages and calls for “a whole system reset”, sets out a series of recommendations for all of the UK’s governments to consider.
Milburn proposes a two-pronged guarantee “that is enshrined in law”. Firstly, an “Opportunity Guarantee”, under which young people aged 18 to 24 will have a statutory entitlement to a place in education, training or work, and a “Support Guarantee”, offering rights to health and practical support.
His report makes a number of recommendations in areas which are devolved but urges the Scottish Government to consider how to implement the “underlying principles”, including “a clear guarantee, accountable local ownership, joined-up support, better use of data and continuing responsibility for the transition into work”.
On reserved areas, it argues for greater incentives for employers to take on young people, such as paying them £3,000 for taking on a young person who has been a Neet for six months. This payment would be bolstered by an additional £2,000 for those facing increased barriers, such as care leavers or disabled young people.
A cut to employer National Insurance contributions (NIC) for 21-to-24-year-olds for five years in the hospitality and retail industries is also recommended. This comes after industry warnings that the NIC increase brought in by the Keir Starmer government has made it harder for businesses to hire young people.
Milburn also proposes “an entirely new benefit system for young people” under which a “New Youth Allowance” would be created. This would replace both the Universal Credit health element and Personal Independence Payment (Pip) benefits.
Speaking in Holyrood on Tuesday afternoon, Swinney said: “There’s a great deal in the Milburn review that the government will consider, and I think it’s a substantial contribution to the debate.”
He added: “There are potentially some significant financial implications that could be negative for the Scottish Government. We need to explore those in detail, and it depends of course on the reaction of the United Kingdom Government.”
Education secretary Mairi McAllan said the Scottish Government would take the “opportunity to collaborate with the UK Government and others” where possible and welcomed the recognition of the different landscape in devolved areas.
She added: “While any action to support young disabled people into work is welcome, it must not come at the expense of essential support. Any changes to UK Government disability benefits or employment support spending could have significant knock-on effects for Scotland's people and budget so we expect to be consulted on any further reforms. Having already cut Scotland's budget by £650m in real terms next year, further cuts as a result of this review would be unacceptable.
“Ultimately, we will collaborate on action which we believe can support young people in Scotland but much of what is recommended for England has been being embedded by the Scottish Government for years.
“Fundamentally, the UK Government needs to grow the UK economy in order to create opportunities for our young people – starting with a full return to the EU and the single market.”
Meanwhile, Scottish Secretary Douglas Alexander said the recommendations went “hand in hand” with the UK Government’s wider devolution agenda.
He said: “We want to ensure young people in every part of Scotland can benefit from this approach and reach their full potential, whether that’s through a training course, an apprenticeship or a first job.
“This work will go hand in hand with the prime minister’s commitment to deepening devolution across Scotland, working in partnership with the Scottish Government to push power out of the centre and into the hands of our cities and regions.”
A version of this article first appeared on Holyrood’s sister website, PoliticsHome.
Holyrood Newsletters
Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe