Clowns to the left of me: The exhausting idiocy of the Scottish Greens
It was a grim week for women. Bookended, as it was, by the absolute horror contained within the detail of the judge’s final deliberations as he sentenced Russell Brand for ten years for rape and sexual assault. And ending with the ridiculous spectacle of the Green MSPs that sit on the equalities committee in the Scottish Parliament determined to follow an anti-women agenda.
Both scenarios are populated by clowns – one by an actual stand-up comic, the other by legislators who reveal a scant regard for the law. And both are connected by a thread of deeply disturbing misogyny – one in the raw and in the vociferous destruction of women through sexual violence, the other cloaked in a veneer of progressive politics that eschews evidence, ignores biology, puts men first, and is willing to sacrifice women’s safety for the sake of an ideology that follows outdated gender stereotypes and crumbles under the skimpiest reference of fact that men cannot be women.
God, I sometimes lose the will with this world and all its idiocy. Being surrounded by the foolish, unwilling to put to one side their own prejudices which blind them to learning, is exhausting. And it does nothing to further the cause of the most put-upon group of people who make up more than half of the world’s population and yet continue to be the object of derision, subjugation and constant sexual attack.
And yes, it’s true, that justice is so rarely seen to be done in the case of rape that we should at least celebrate that one glimmer of optimism in this whole sordid affair that saw Brand found guilty and now in prison where sadly he inevitably continues to exert control in an attempt to see incarceration for sexual violence as an astute career move rather than punishment for a hideous crime.
But there seems little point in rehearsing the misdemeanours of Brand. After all, they come from the oldest playbook in the world of sexual politics where women are there to be controlled by men. And let’s face it, was anyone – other than the gullible men on the left who lapped up his avant-garde projection of being the next progressive messiah – surprised by what a wolf in sheep’s clothing he turned out to be? The monster was operating in plain sight and gallus enough to be boasting of his abhorrent acts of sexual violence, making jokes of his sadistic practices and revealing throughout a fundamental hatred of women. And all the while, getting applause and getting paid.
Is there any real value in trying to understand why he did what he did and agonising over whether we can learn lessons from it to educate our men and boys when, seriously, what is there to understand about a shattered moral compass, a descent into depravity and an elevation to celebrity? He’s a man, so the groundwork was already prepared. And I would simply draw a straight line from Brand’s vile, chauvinistic father to the subsequent indecency of his son and link that back to every angry, porn-addled bloke that only ever views women through a sexual lens and was given license by a man whose currency was rooted in despicable behaviour.
What is there truly for us to take from the Brand episode other than it was staring us in the face? We made him a star, laughed at his jokes, turned a blind eye and enabled him to carry on. Can you really believe that we’ve reached a nadir with Brand and that everything will now miraculously change, that misogyny will disappear and men and boys will be put on the path to righteousness driven by their contrition over this man’s indecency? I think not because Brand is not the exception – he is, to some extent, the rule.
And what was even more disturbing for me, that makes me more nervous for women and the way misogyny manifests, was watching female elected politicians so blinded by their own biased world view that they could display such ignorance of the law and its associated guidance, and in doing so showed so little regard for the women that the law is designed to protect.
They are meant to be legislators, not there to argue for the law to be ignored or produce fanciful anecdotes as evidence of fact. And how dare they damn others in accusations of indulging in outdated gender stereotypes when they use them to validate outrageous claims such as a cancer sufferer who has lost her hair being viewed as less feminine. And worse, lacking in so little empathy that they direct that description to an expert witness who was herself left bald by her own cancer treatment and also happens to be the woman that fought for biological sex to be recognised in law. For goodness’ sake, where’s the humanity?
In my day, real feminists would have been out on the streets protesting the fact that the law designed to protect them was being breached, that single-sex spaces were no longer that. And we’d have been screaming from the rooftops about a glaring anomaly in the way the law was being implemented that didn’t just allow men to access all areas but actively encouraged it.
And I ask, would Donald Dewar, the father of the nation, the architect of devolution, have ever imagined a day that politicians of the left would show more sympathy for rapists being housed in a prison designed for men than for the women that the law was designed to protect?
And would he have ever understood how it has come to pass that For Women Scotland, the organisation that bravely took the government to court to get the law restored to recognising that woman and sex in the Equality Act refers to biological sex, could be treated not with respect in the parliament he helped reconvene, but with hostility?
If politicians are serious about tackling violence against women and girls, and understand that deep-seated misogyny needs to be addressed as a start, they cannot expect to challenge systemic male behaviour while at the same time displaying such fundamental disrespect to women themselves by not recognising that single-sex spaces are an essential, legal and necessary tool in the armoury against male violence.
And when they allow male demands to supersede women’s rights, they are instrumental in creating the societal landscape that allows the prodigies of Brand to thrive.
Holyrood Newsletters
Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe