Subscribe to Holyrood updates

Newsletter sign-up


Follow us

Scotland’s fortnightly political & current affairs magazine


Subscribe to Holyrood
by Mandy Rhodes
26 October 2020
Brexit Britain is a cold and hostile place for child refugees


Brexit Britain is a cold and hostile place for child refugees

Labour peer Alf Dubs was just six years old in 1939 when late one night his mother took him to the train station in Prague and bundled him and a small suitcase onto a train bound for London.

The bare wooden seats lining the carriages of the Kindertransport were filled with children who, like Dubs, pressed their faces up against the windows of the departing trains, trying to get one last glimpse of fast disappearing parents. The words ‘see you soon’ echoed down the platform, but most of the parents – who nearly all perished in the Holocaust – would never see their children again.

Hundreds of unaccompanied children were on those trains and for most it was the first time they had ever been away from home. Dubs sat quietly and upright for almost the entire journey – a small package of food left unopened on his knee.

At various stops, German soldiers would board and march up and down the carriages, stopping occasionally to kick open suitcases and rake through the contents on the floor. Children sobbed silently, too afraid to make a noise.

As the train crossed the Dutch border Dubs remembers the older children erupting into loud cheers. He didn’t know why, but later understood it was because they realised, they were now safe from the Nazis.

Dubs himself, arrived in Liverpool Street Station two-days later, one of the few to be met by a parent. His father had fled to Britain a few months earlier in search of a safe refuge for Jews.

Now nearly 90, Lord Dubs describes his flight to freedom with great humility, remembering all that were left behind and those who perished. “I was just a small boy who got on a train,” he tells me.

Dubs is a man who tries to see the good in anyone or any situation. A man perhaps grateful for his lot. But nothing, not even his attempts at minimising what he, as a tiny boy, must have gone through, can disguise the horrific backdrop to his early life and how it shaped who he became - a campaigning Labour politician and chair of the Refugee Council, who later poured his energies into being a member of the House of Lords and trying to ensure that children fleeing danger would always find a sanctuary in Britain.

I last met Dubs in 2017 on the day the Lords approved the bill to trigger Article 50 allowing for the process to begin for the UK to exit the European Union. For a man whose own story of survival is woven into the fabric of Europe, he was visibly pained about what Brexit would mean for refugees and vulnerable children that could become easy prey for criminals, danger and people traffickers.

And three years on, his fears have been realised when last week Tory MPs – bar six honourable dissenters – voted down his amendment to a bill that would have continued to offer the legal protection currently afforded under EU legislation to unaccompanied children of refugees seeking to be reunited with family in the UK.

Dubs said the vote would be a test of the humanitarian principles of MPs. And on that, they failed.

There may no longer be an explicit commitment by this government to a hostile environment in its approach to immigration but for those abandoned children, stateless and without family, Brexit Britain must appear a cold and hostile place. And to Dubs, a spectre of the past.

Holyrood Newsletters

Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe

Stay in the know with our fortnightly magazine

Stay in the know with our fortnightly magazine


Popular reads
Back to top