Menu
Subscribe to Holyrood updates

Newsletter sign-up

Subscribe

Follow us

Scotland’s fortnightly political & current affairs magazine

Subscribe

Subscribe to Holyrood
by Louise Wilson
22 November 2026
Sketch: MSPs raise a pint to pubs

Credit: Iain Green

Sketch: MSPs raise a pint to pubs

The humble public house is the last bastion of Scottish social life, an MSP declares to the Scottish Parliament. Take a guess to which party this speaker belongs.

A small hint: his UK leader has carefully cultivated an image as a man of the people, just a normal bloke who loves a cheeky pint. Nige is always down the pub, speaking ‘common sense’.

But enough about politicians down south. Jamie Langan, a Reform MSP for South Scotland, wants to have a wee blether about how great local boozers are up here. “The pub remains one of the last truly social public places we have left,” he tells the chamber. They are about “far more than alcohol”, he says. That’s just an added benefit, something to help lubricate the social stuff. And he wants more to be done to stop pubs from closing.

“This shouldn’t be a partisan issue,” he says. “I suspect almost every one of us has a favourite pub, a local,” he adds, buttering up his colleagues before making some partisan points about tax, regulation and whose fault the closures are.

He is particularly aggrieved that a pub which “survived Jacobite uprisings, survived economic depressions, survived two World Wars” is closing. Earlier this year the Crown Inn in Biggar called last orders for the last time. No one was expecting a history lesson in this debate, but maybe that’s just Langan’s favourite tipple.

Pubs, he says, are woven into the “cultural and social fabric” of Scotland and must not become a “relic of the past”. “If we value our local pub, we should use it,” he demands. “We need strong community institutions, and the local pub is arguably the most important of those institutions.” And that really does explain a lot about Scotland’s relationship with alcohol.

But then that’s another thing Langan has a bee in his bonnet about. “Social drinking is not something that needs to be apologised for,” he insists. “It is a normal and valued part of Scottish life, and the nanny state needs to give it a wee bit of breathing room.” Nanny, stop closing all the pubs!

Labour MSP Carol Mochan believes it is wrong to “ignore the reality of alcohol-related harms”. While she acknowledges the “sense of loss” felt in places like Biggar, all of this must be approached with “balance”, she argues.

Langan is perplexed. A “public licensed place… is not where the issue of problem alcohol consumption is”, he insists. Apparently, alcoholics or those at risk of alcohol harm don’t frequent bars. Who knew?

“I would probably disagree,” says Mochan, fairly. She says drinking is “a bit normalised” but “there is a place for socialising with alcohol” in Scotland. Cheers to that. But that is why the question isn’t about supporting pubs or public health, she says, but both.

Langan’s colleague Helen McDade pushes back. “Actually, at least if people are going to the pub and having a drink, the drink’s more expensive, people might nurse a pint or two while they have an evening chat,” she argues. She really needn’t have prefaced her speech by admitting she is “not in pubs very often” – clearly that is the case if she thinks people aren’t regularly getting mashed in the local.

Yet other than the slight disagreement over whether alcoholics go to pubs, the rest of the debate is broadly consensual. Tory Craig Hoy gets in early with an intervention to apologise for the fact he won’t be making a speech because he is “skiving off on a pub quiz”. Langan welcomes the bold admission, saying that “going off to support the trade is as good an excuse as any not to be here”. Not an excuse usually acceptable in parliament, but there’s a first for everything.

SNP MSP Emma Roddick admits that when she’s asked for recommendations on what to do in her hometown of Inverness, she has to “think to myself ‘don’t just name pubs’”. “We’ve got plenty of things you can do,” she insists, not very convincingly.

Reform’s David Kirkwood says pubs can provide “some form of normality” to small places without much else going on. I’m sure the fact he was following Roddick’s speech about Inverness was just a coincidence.

Kirkwood continues: “Pubs used to be called the people’s parliament – it’s where people go to talk and share some ideas.” Has he revealed more about his party’s approach to politics than he should have?

And closing the debate, pubs minister Tom Arthur insists the government “has been quick and upfront to acknowledge” problems facing the sector. He says little about what it is actually doing about those problems, beyond reviews and a vague commitment to reduce that scourge of business – red tape.

But that’s by the by. He agrees that a pub is a “fulcrum of community cohesion”, and they must be protected even as lifestyles shift towards “moderation and sustainability”. Whatever that means.

Slàinte to another high-quality debate in the Scottish Parliament.

Holyrood Newsletters

Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe

Tags

Sketch

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox

Subscribe

Popular reads
Back to top