Scottish Government rejects deal with UK Government over EU powers, while Welsh Government reaches compromise

Written by Tom Freeman on 24 April 2018 in News

Welsh Government call deal "a step in the right direction", but it is a step too far for the Scottish Government

Michael Russell - Scottish Parliament

The Scottish Government has rejected the latest deal with the UK Government over powers repatriated from Brussels after Brexit.

In a statement to MSPs, Scotland’s Brexit minister Michael Russell said the latest compromise had been rejected due to a clause which would restrict the Scottish Parliament’s powers for a period of seven years.

Meanwhile, the Welsh Government announced it had reached an agreement with UK ministers over the terms.

Both the Scottish and Welsh governments had labelled the original drafting of the UK-wide EU Withdrawal bill a “power grab”, and had passed emergency legislation to transfer EU law to their respective parliaments if an agreement couldn’t be reached.

The UK Government said it had made a “considerable offer” by way of a compromise.

Russell told MSPs Scottish ministers that Clause 11 of the EU Withdrawal bill – which refers to powers normally devolved to the Scottish and Welsh parliaments – as the “main sticking point”.

"We cannot support any proposal that would enable the powers of the Scottish parliament to be constrained, he said.

“The UK government has no mandate to undermine the powers of this parliament.”



Scottish Conservative and Labour MSPs suggested Russell had been prepared to accept the deal before an intervention from First Minister Nicola Sturgeon.

Scottish Conservative constitution spokesman Adam Tomkins said: “The Welsh Government has signed up to this deal. Yet Nicola Sturgeon, alone, refuses because she prefers to pick a fight with the rest of the UK in order to keep her obsession with a second independence referendum alive.”

Scottish Labour’s Brexit spokesperson Neil Findlay MSP said: “This process should not be about constitutional wrangling between the SNP and the Tories. It is about protecting jobs, consumer safeguards and our environment. 

“We have been told time and again that the SNP would act in good faith and try to secure the right deal with the UK’s governments that would protect devolution. 

“Reports that a deal was on the table, only to be vetoed by Nicola Sturgeon, would be a betrayal of the Scottish Parliament’s good faith.

“The fact the Government of Wales has reached an agreement but the Scottish Government has not is a real concern.”

Speaking to the BBC after the deal was struck, Welsh Finance Secretary Mark Drakeford said: "London has changed its position so that all powers and policy areas rest in Cardiff, unless specified to be temporarily held by the UK government.

"These will be areas where we all agree common, UK-wide rules are needed for a functioning UK internal market.

"In a devolved UK the respective governments need to deal with each other as equals and this agreement is a step in the right direction."



Related Articles

SNP MEP Alyn Smith calls for extension of the Article 50 timetable
9 November 2018

A group of MEPs has demanded more time in the talks to avoid a No Deal or a so-called “Blind Brexit”

Information Commissioner to fine Leave.EU and Arron Banks’ firm for misuse of customer data
6 November 2018

Marketing emails were sent promoting Eldon Insurance and the Leave campaign without recipients’ permission

Exclusive: Home Office arrested and deported dozens of Europeans for sleeping rough in Scotland last year
19 July 2018

Home Office arrested and removed 26 European nationals from Scotland for sleeping rough on the streets in a move now deemed unlawful

Great Repeal Bill “an attack on the founding principles of devolution”, say Scottish and Welsh governments
13 July 2017

Publishing the EU (Withdrawal) Bill, UK Brexit Secretary David Davis called on MPs to “work together” as negotiations over the UK’s exit from the EU move...

Related Sponsored Articles

Associate feature: 5 ways IoT is transforming the public sector
5 February 2018

Vodafone explores some of the ways IoT is significantly improving public sector service delivery

Share this page