Motion of no confidence in Police Scotland defeated

Written by Tom Freeman on 7 December 2017 in News

Liberal Democrats criticised for no confidence motion in Police Scotland

Police Scotland - credit Ninian Reid

The Liberal Democrats came under fire from MSPs of other parties as the party's motion of no confidence in Police Scotland was defeated at Holyrood.

The party called for an independent commission to look at previous reforms which saw local police forces merged into a national force in 

Liam McArthur said a succession of resignations, suspensions and early retirements had weakened confidence in Scotland's national police force and governing body the Scottish Police Authority.


He told MSPs: "We have every confidence in our police officers and staff. We have no confidence, though, in the structures in which they are being asked to operate. We need change."

But the motion was fiercely criticised by Calum Steele of the Scottish Police Federation on twitter.

Justice Secretary Michael Matheson said: "If the member is committed to being 100 per cent behind police officers in the job that they are doing, supporting a motion of no confidence in Police Scotland is a bizarre way of going about it."

And former cop John Finnie MSP, justice spokesperson for the Scottish Greens, slammed the motion for being an "overt attack" on Police Scotland's structure and strategy.

"The strategic functions of Police Scotland are delivering results, whether in organised crime, human trafficking or terrorism. The real issue is local accountability," he said.

"We need to see early and comprehensive devolution of resources within Police Scotland, including finance, to deliver genuine local policing which can be robustly scrutinised by democratically elected committees.

"We need to challenge those with the romantic notion that in the old days everything was good in policing. But there's no doubt the SPA has a way to go to build a positive reputation.

"With devolution of decision-making in line with local policing plans we can reflect real community needs."

Scottish Labour's Claire Baker called for "increasing capacity and devolution" in both Police Scotland and the SPA.

The Scottish Conservatives, however, backed the Liberal Democrat motion. 




Related Articles

Brexit comparisons with heroes and anti-heroes proliferate, but the real power lies with the courts
23 September 2019

A decision is expected this week by the Supreme Court on whether it was lawful for Boris Johnson to suspend parliament

Scottish Parliament should be given powers to scrutinise future referendum questions, committee says
17 September 2019

The Delegated Powers and Law Reform Committee said that there should be legislation for referendum questions on issues of national importance

Claim that Scottish judges are biased against Brexit sparks Tory row
12 September 2019

Downing Street had to confirm its confidence in the judiciary after a source suggested MPs “chose the Scottish courts for a reason”

Suspension of parliament 'unlawful', Court of Session rules
11 September 2019

A panel of judges in Scotland’s highest civil court found that the decision to suspend was “motivated by the improper purpose of stymying Parliament”.

Share this page