Twenty years on, Scots walk a little taller for having the Scottish Parliament

Written by Mandy Rhodes on 5 May 2019 in Comment

Mandy Rhodes on how 20 years of devolution have changed Scotland

Image credit: David Anderson

Scotland went to the polls 20 years ago this week to elect its first MSPs to the Scottish Parliament. And so, too, Holyrood magazine was born. Two decades on and we all continue to robustly debate our constitutional future and question whether devolution was a process and not an event.

In that time, Scotland has been taken to the very brink of independence and yet we still question what the settled will of the people really means.

But despite the angst and sometimes navel-gazing over constitutional minutiae that really only matters to us, what I know is that we have all been changed by a parliament that has, by turns, reflected the very best and the worst of us.

Looking back at the group photograph of that first intake of MSPs, of course, they have all aged, some are sadly no longer with us, but there’s something else, something less tangible, something about the way we have grown, the way we think about ourselves, the way we talk and the way we hold ourselves.

Scots walk a little taller for having the Scottish Parliament.

And I see it in my son. Born in 1997 just as Tony Blair came into office, Kyle is the very epitome of the devolution generation. He doesn’t suffer the Scottish cringe; he doesn’t puff himself up by bringing others down and he is more comfortable in his Scottish skin than I ever was at his age.

He is global, outward-looking and he sets his ambitions high. And he sees the Scottish Parliament as the seat of power and looks on Westminster with a degree of disdain.

And no wonder. The Scottish Parliament is talking to him. It is discussing maters of social justice, exploring boundaries, expanding horizons, wanting more for Scotland and it has told him that his generation has a voice. It gave him the vote at 16.

My son’s view of MSPs isn’t tarnished by the cynicism of his parents’ generation that were mired in debates about caliber, or class, and of what was the measure of political competence. He doesn’t hold with a view that you must have travelled through Oxbridge to qualify for great things or to tell others what to do. And there is an egalitarian air to his generation born into devolution that is soaked into their very bones.

They don’t get so bogged down in details about diversity and discrimination because for them, we are just who we are, that we are all Jock Tamson’s bairns – and it is our children teaching us that to be true.

I reflect on that very first piece of legislation passed by MSPs in 1999, a mental health act aimed at closing a loophole in the law and hailed across Europe for its innovation, for its sense and for its humanity.

It wasn’t a tartanised version of something exported from down south and with it we were finding a Scottish solution to a Scottish problem, rooted in who we are. Just what Donald Dewar had wanted us to do.

And those early laws on mental health, land reform, scrapping Section 28, on homelessness, free personal care and the smoking ban, they reflected a Scottishness, a desire to do things our way and for the common good.

Yes, there were problems – we were impatient, our laws weren’t always as well-crafted as they should be, and our debates could be clumsy, but our incipient parliamentarians were shaping Scotland’s future in a way that spoke to the world about who we were – how we loved, lived and cared.

And these were things that would never have found time in Westminster, had never found time at Westminster.

More cynical commentators than I, who get paid for peddling bitterness about the place they now call work, have questioned those first parliamentarians’ abilities and those who come after. They gauge them against those that sit in a parliament, centuries-old, that has been shaped, developed and crafted with age. And they find them wanting. But against what measure? The ability to mess up Brexit, to award ferry contracts to companies with no ferries, to leak sensitive security information or to represent a devolved nation with no understanding of its politics? I don’t agree.

And neither do I feel the need to criticise our politicians for not springing from the same private school, Oxbridge-educated prototype that fills the Westminster benches. Instead, I can turn to men of stature, like George Reid, whose background in the Red Cross and in its peace-making equipped him well for the Presiding Officer’s chair. Women like Winnie Ewing, who smashed glass ceilings or Margo MacDonald, broadcaster, campaigner and doughty warrior in the fight against discrimination. Doctors like Sam Galbraith and Richard Simpson, who brought such intellect to the chamber. Lawyers, teachers, community workers, trade unionists. These were the people who fought to represent Scotland and they were not handed their political pass as they picked up their degrees in PPE.

And just last week, listening to Iain Gray MSP, a former maths teacher, who was elected in 1999, who lost his seat in 2003 but returned in 2007, talking emotionally in the chamber about his experiences as an aid worker with Oxfam when he travelled to Rwanda 25 years ago in the wake of the genocide, I was grateful that he had chosen to bring that wisdom, that empathy, to this place.

The photograph of the class of 1999 captures a moment in time, a past that has flown by in the blink of an eye, but parliamentarians like Gray have in that time helped propel Scotland to a different future. A better future. And that is something to celebrate.



Related Articles

Brexit has challenged intergovernmental relations ‘within an inch of their lives’
12 July 2019

UK and Scottish government relations are “under pressure like never before”, SNP MP Pete Wishart has told the House of Commons

Fiona Hyslop travels to Brussels to outline commitment to European cooperation
9 July 2019

External affairs secretary will point to cooperation in renewable energy research as well as European funding for remote infrastructure projects as evidence of how Scotland benefits from EU...

Division now infects every part of our politics
8 July 2019

"The truth is, if I voted yes in another referendum, it would be in grief and hope rather than glee"

Humza Yousaf welcomes Police Scotland Brexit contingency plans
5 July 2019

The Justice Minister has welcomed the decision to put around 300 police officers on standby to deal with any Brexit-related issues on 31 October

Related Sponsored Articles

Associate feature: 5 ways IoT is transforming the public sector
5 February 2018

Vodafone explores some of the ways IoT is significantly improving public sector service delivery

Share this page