Follow us

Scotland’s fortnightly political & current affairs magazine


Subscribe to Holyrood
Keeping the faith: John McDonnell prepares for power

Image credit:Alister Thorpe

Keeping the faith: John McDonnell prepares for power

Like out-of-date milk in the fridge and one forgotten jacket on the coatstand, the forlorn flipchart, the paper fading, the felt-tip scrawl of once bright ideas now almost illegible, can be found in every office.

The one standing behind John McDonnell’s desk in his Westminster office might look the same but the scrawl, once deciphered, has a little more drama. At the top are the words General Election Footing, emboldened and underlined, and beneath are listed six steps the shadow chancellor believes will help Labour win power in an election that, he strongly suspects, is only a few months away.

As Boris Johnson continued his nationwide tour last week amid mounting speculation that he is planning to engineer a standoff with the EU and MPs to justify an October election, McDonnell continued working on his charts and graphs.

And, as a former trainee priest, and despite Labour trailing behind the Conservatives in the polls despite years of Tory austerity, a delayed EU exit and a change of prime minister, McDonnell is keeping the faith. He believes Johnson, despite his protestations, is likely to call an election before his do-or-die Brexit Day on 31 October and believes attack will be the best form of defence for Labour.

Indeed, one of the instructions on his flipchart action plan – after treasury policies, spending commitments and “big ticket” items – is ‘Attack and Rebuttal.” It is a tactic the shadow chancellor is not unfamiliar with. He has had to spend a lot of time over his 40-year political career addressing how he, and now more recently, how the party led by Jeremy Corbyn, are painted by political opponents and the media. And controversy has been his constant companion,

His entry in Who’s Who states that his life’s purpose is to “ferment the overthrow of capitalism” and as deputy to Ken Livingstone in the old GLC days of the 1980s, he was reportedly sacked for being too left wing. This, before he joined parliament and said he would “swim through vomit” to vote against the Conservative’s Welfare Bill and had thrown a copy of Mao Zedong’s Little Red Book across the Commons in his idiosyncratic reply to the then Chancellor, George Osborne and his Autumn Statement.

I sit down with McDonnell the day after he has had to deny that he is plotting against his longtime friend, Corbyn, that he has called for Corbyn’s closest aides to be sacked, and that the party is riven by splits because of its opaque position on Brexit and its inability to close-down recurring accusations of anti-Semitism.

“Look, Jeremy and I are friends, we always will have a conversation, he’s a mate, we’ve been working together nearly 40 years and we’ve always had each other’s backs. At times, it’s only been me and him supporting some campaign or other when others wouldn’t touch it with a barge pole, but we did because we believed in something, so we’ve always been there for each other and if we disagree, we disagree, but at the end of the day we back each other up.

“There can be frustration, in the sense that he does things by building consensus whereas I can be a bit ‘this is my view, take it or leave it’, but I recognize that Jeremy brings people in, he listens to them, and counters some of the arguments and myths as well.

“We are different in our approach but that’s why we compliment each other and there is no split.”

McDonnell tried to stand for leader of the party in 2007 after Tony Blair stood down and again in 2010 after Gordon Brown’s resignation. Is he after the top job now?

“No.Jeremy is the style of leader that we need right now. Someone who can bring the country together, a consensus builder. I mean, just contrast him with Boris Johnson. Yes, he’s older, more experienced, much wiser and someone who yes, will take a bit of time to finalise decisions, because he’s listening to all of the sides.

“Boris Johnson jumps in with two big feet. Can you imagine the embarrassment the country’s going to get as a result of that? I want someone who is completely dependable, who is really willing to listen, comes to a view, explains that view, and then be absolutely determined. That’s Jeremy.”

But that can be a long and convoluted road. On the two issues that have caused Labour to lose so much support; Brexit and anti-Semitism, Corbyn has taken too long to explain the party’s position. McDonnell, who will be at the Edinburgh Fringe for two question and answer sessions on Tuesday and Wednesday, is remarkably open about the mistakes he believes the party has made in dealing with anti-Semitism.

 “We are now a mass membership organization of 500,000 and we reflect the rest of society. So, one, there has been a rise of anti-Semitism across our country and Europe as well, that’s the first thing. The second thing I think we were, all of us, and this isn’t just about the Labour Party, it’s about our society overall, I think we were conceited and thought we had dealt with anti-Semitism, and we hadn’t. We didn’t recognize how far back it goes in our history, how it’s embedded in us.

“When it got raised, we weren’t fast enough or ruthless enough, mechanisms weren’t in place and funding wasn’t there and that’s why we changed things. We’ve got a new General Secretary who has come in and has approved a lot since then, but the issue for us is actually that we’ve wanted to go much further.

“You can’t be let off the hook by dismissing it as just nuance of language, no, it isn’t, it is racism. If you don’t understand it’s racism, then you have a responsibility to learn about it and that’s where we are now in terms of making sure our members do.

“We haven’t learnt enough about anti-Semitism in our society, and we also haven’t learnt enough about how when you cause offence, you accept it, honestly accept it, and make honest reparations. I think that’s where we are now as a party as a result of all we’ve gone through, and we are still going through a pretty hard time about this.

“We’ve got to do two things; we’ve got to be ruthless in dealing with those people who are clearly anti-Semitic and clearly doing it not out of ignorance but out of purpose and then secondly those ones who are repeating stuff that they don’t even understand, is racist, making sure they are challenged and offered the opportunity of education and if that doesn’t work, out then they go.”

“It is distressing and upsetting but we will come out of it stronger and better.”

But, while his party has been dogged by their failure to root out anti-Semites, Labour’s tortuous progress towards building and selling a clear policy on Brexit is, to many observers, an equally clear and present threat to the party’s future as a political force.

Tony Blair’s former spin doctor, Alastair Campbell, a lifelong Labour member who has urged the party to come out clearly against Brexit and for a second referendum, last week said he no longer wished to be in a party led by Jeremy Corbyn and said Labour faced an “existential crisis.”

Flatly dismssing claims that his party’s leader did not campaign hard enough for Remain in 2016 and remains secretly happy for Britain to Brexit, McDonnell said: “It’s interesting because we argued consistently that we wanted Remain, we lost the referendum but tried to respect that vote.

“We immediately said that our job was to get the best deal we possibly could, and we were doing everything we possibly could; motions to make sure that there was a more open and transparent process in negotiations, motions to make sure that we blocked a no deal. We won that overwhelmingly.

“All the way along we were doing everything we possibly could do prevent the damage or limit the damage that we believe will happen with a no-deal and where have we gotten to now, which is extraordinary, is that in the last Treasury questions in the House of Commons with Philip Hammond, I asked him to explain what no deal means, and he said a £90 billion hit on the economy which when translated that into the real world, means business investment decisions not being made, jobs being lost and the long term future of our manufacturing base being undermined.

“If there’s a referendum tomorrow I will vote remain, I will campaign for remain, Jeremy will campaign for remain, Labour will campaign for remain.

“But we’re working on the basis now that Johnson will get the usual little bit of a bounce in polls, will be a bit like Theresa May and go walk in the Welsh hills or being him, more like wander around a few clubs in Chelsea, and he’ll come out and decide he’ll call an election. 

“I think he’ll call it September for October because he wants to change this parliament because he couldn’t get a deal through this parliament. So that’s what we are preparing for and we will win it.”

For details and tickets for John McDonnell’s Q&As see or 

Read the most recent article written by Mandy Rhodes - Exclusive: Interview with Nicola Sturgeon on turning 50

Stay in the know with our fortnightly magazine

Stay in the know with our fortnightly magazine


Popular reads
Back to top