Subscribe to Holyrood updates

Newsletter sign-up


Follow us

Scotland’s fortnightly political & current affairs magazine


Subscribe to Holyrood
by Mandy Rhodes
16 November 2018
Brexit does now mean something, if only that it’s a fudge

Brexit does now mean something, if only that it’s a fudge

Mandy Rhodes - Image credit: Holyrood

Theresa May is the Weeble of UK politics.

No matter how far she is pushed, no matter how difficult the terrain, just like the 1970s roly-poly cult toy, she just won’t fall down.

And my, for her sheer tenacity and resilience, she must be admired.

She is impossible to read. Even in these last few days which could be her last in office, she retains a business-like formality to just ‘getting the job done’.

Brexit was never her choice and the architects of the impossible have all left the building while she has valiantly soldiered on, seeing it as her public duty as prime minister to deliver.  

The problem is and always was, deliver on what?

What people voted for and what divided her party, was a circle that could never be squared.

But in the face of such futility, she has simply repeated specific mantras as if trying to persuade herself, more than anyone, that yes, she is strong and stable, that Brexit will mean Brexit and that nothing will change.

But at last something has changed. Brexit does now mean something, if only that it’s a fudge. Out of Europe but still sort of in it.

May doesn’t even pretend that the deal she is offering is any good, but it is, as she frequently points out, the best on offer and perish the alternative.

Which is kind of how she became prime minister in the first place.

May is more administrator than leader and the main weapon in her arsenal against the fevered speculation about a leadership bid is the threat of a general election.

That makes me blush on her behalf.

Clearly a bright and able politician, her main line of defence boils down to the threat of Jeremy Corbyn in No 10 rather than in an assured confidence in her own abilities.

And so, the questions that have dominated negotiations – always more about the wrangling within the Tory party than with the actual EU – have come to a dramatic head.

There is a deal, of sorts, now on the table, but with it, the second of Theresa May’s Brexit Secretaries has gone and the promise of more Brexiteers to follow.

And while every Cabinet resignation has so far referred to the Brexit plan being a threat to the make-up of the union, the Secretary of State for Scotland, David Mundell, despite his previous threat to quit along with his Scottish leader, Ruth Davidson, should Brexit pose an existential threat to the constitution, has stuck more to the deal than to his guns.

And thus, answered the question of whether he is Scotland’s man in the Cabinet or the Cabinet’s man in Scotland.

Meanwhile, chez Davidson, the Scottish Conservative leader, currently on maternity leave, has probably never more welcomed her current role of changing nappies rather than being on the front-line as the proverbial hits the Brexit fan.

Brexit has been dominated by Tory party theatricals and the psycho-drama is far from over.

“Normally you would all have your hands in the air,” May gently chastised the gathered press as she closed her will-she-won’t-she speech on Thursday.

They meanwhile, hadn’t quite appreciated she’d finished. If they were waiting for the punchline, that may be still to come.

Holyrood Newsletters

Holyrood provides comprehensive coverage of Scottish politics, offering award-winning reporting and analysis: Subscribe

Read the most recent article written by Mandy Rhodes - Fiona Hyslop: The feeling of unity is already palpable in the SNP.

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox

Get award-winning journalism delivered straight to your inbox


Popular reads
Back to top