David Cameron dismisses concerns over TTIP as “the reddest of red herrings”

Written by Liam Kirkaldy on 4 May 2016 in News

Leaked documents suggest talks over TTIP have stalled because of “irreconcilable” differences between the EU and US positions

David Cameron has dismissed claims the Transatlantic Trade and Investment Partnership (TTIP) deal between the EU and the US could jeopardise the future of public services as “the reddest of red herrings”.

Documents leaked by Greenpeace earlier this week suggest talks over TTIP have stalled because of “irreconcilable” differences between the EU and US positions on environmental protection.

Critics have suggested the trade deal would allow private companies to interfere with national regulatory decisions.


Sketch: David Coburn arrives at the Scottish Parliament to talk TTIP

John Swinney rejects idea higher taxes would lead to exodus of high earners

Alistair Darling: European Union exit could put £250bn of British trade at risk

SNP MP Margaret Ferrier referred the Prime Minister to the leaked documents, with the MP for Rutherglen and Hamilton West suggesting TTIP “makes unacceptable concessions in respect of public health and safety regulations, opening the doors for US investors to sue for loss of profits”.

But Cameron rejected concerns, saying the NHS is completely protected under the agreement, which he said could bring billions in investment.

In PMQs Ferrier asked: “Will the Prime Minister recognise the concern raised by the French President and tell this House what protections his government are seeking for the National Health Service and public services?”

Cameron responded: “This is the reddest of red herrings, I have to say. The health service is completely protected under this agreement, as it is under others.

“There are all sorts of reasons why people might be against free trade and wanting to see an expansion of trade, investment and jobs, but I think people ought to be honest about it and say that they do not want to see those things happen, rather than finding total red herrings to get in the way of something that could add tens of billion pounds to our economy and bring jobs and investment to our country.”

Jorgo Riss, the director of Greenpeace EU, told the Guardian the documents provide “an unparalleled look at the scope of US demands to lower or circumvent EU protections for environment and public health as part of TTIP”.

He said: “The EU position is very bad, and the US position is terrible. The prospect of a TTIP compromising within that range is an awful one.

“The way is being cleared for a race to the bottom in environmental, consumer protection and public health standards.”



Related Articles

Fergus Ewing urges UK government to "come clean" on plans for fisheries policy after Brexit
10 November 2017

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon claims the UK Government has not honoured promises to share information on the progress of Brexit negotiations

Campaigners urge ministers to ensure National Investment Bank boosts low carbon infrastructure
15 December 2017

Environmental campaigners welcomed plans for £340m in capital funding for the National Investment Bank, while urging ministers to ensure it helps develop Scotland’s low carbon...

Budget 2017: Environmental groups question North Sea tax break
23 November 2017

Oil industry welcomed news that Philip Hammond will allow the tax history of oil and gas fields to be transferred after a sale, allowing buyers to claim greater relief when it comes to...

Share this page