Keeping Barnett formula 'not appropriate' after Brexit, warns Institute for Fiscal Studies

Written by Liam Kirkaldy on 24 April 2018 in News

Pledge to maintain Barnett formula one of the key parts of the Vow, made by the Conservatives, Labour and the Lib Dems in the run up to the 2014 independence referendum

The Barnett formula will no longer be fit for purpose after Brexit, according to the Institute for Fiscal Studies.

A pledge to maintain the Barnett formula was one of the key parts of the Vow, made by the Conservatives, Labour and the Lib Dems in the run up to the 2014 independence referendum.

But while Scotland is set to receive €5.6bn in funding from the pre-allocated funds for the 2014–2020 EU budget period, the future of funding arrangements within the UK have been thrown into doubt following the Brexit vote.

With the Scottish Parliament's Finance and Constitution Committee currently gathering evidence on post-Brexit funding, the IFS warned that the Barnett formula is unsuitable as a replacement funding mechanism, arguing that it takes no account of differences in funding needs or population growth between nations, or of the different outcomes achieved by funding.

When Scotland loses access to EU funding for agriculture, economic development and innovation, the IFS recommended that funding decisions should be taken at a UK-wide level, rather than by allocating all replacement funding to the Scottish Government to distribute to specific projects.

David Phillips, associate director at the Institute for Fiscal Studies, said: “The UK is set to receive around €8 billion a year from the EU budget over the next 3 years. But big choices loom about how much to spend on programmes to replace the EU's agriculture, regional development and research and innovation funding after 2020, and how that spending should be allocated and managed.

“The Scottish Parliament's Finance and Constitution Committee has asked whether the Barnett formula would be an appropriate way to allocate funding to the devolved governments. We don't think it would. It's also not clear that funding decisions are always best taken at a devolved level.

“In science and innovation, for instance, remaining in EU-wide programmes or integrating funding with existing UK-wide schemes would help ensure the best projects – with the biggest gains to society – receive support. This would be good for the UK and for Scotland – which has historically punched well above its weight when competing for science and innovation funds.”



Related Articles

Small businesses unprepared to cope with climate change, study finds
24 December 2018

Survey finds that just 39 per cent of smaller businesses feel they are either fully or partly prepared for the effects of rising global temperatures

Promote the aquaculture industry to school leavers and graduates, urges HIE
23 May 2018

Highlands and Islands Enterprise highlights a gender imbalance in both the industry and education system, as well as an ageing workforce

Scotland could achieve net zero emissions by 2045, study finds
23 January 2019

The study, produced by Vivid Economics, said carbon sinks will play a crucial role in balancing remaining emissions

Digital infrastructure must be given same priority as traditional construction projects, says Michael Matheson
10 October 2018

The Scottish Government this week announced plans to establish an infrastructure commission to advise ministers on how spending can deliver maximum benefit for the economy

Related Sponsored Articles

Associate feature: 5 ways IoT is transforming the public sector
5 February 2018

Vodafone explores some of the ways IoT is significantly improving public sector service delivery

Associate feature: Don’t let security cloud your views on digital transformation
16 April 2019

89 per cent of organisations say digital transformation is key to delivering their business strategy, and see a need to move to the cloud to achieve this. BT explains how to dispel myths about...

Associate feature: Encourage an open ethos to secure your organisation
2 April 2019

BT's CISO public sector, Hugh Tatton-Brown, joins Tech Talk’s recent podcast to discuss the current state of the security...

Associate Feature: Not all ethical hackers are equal
26 March 2019

At a time when global organisations are trying to keep costs low to be competitive, BT details how security testing is not...

Share this page