MSPs seek clarification on use of evidence in cases of wildlife crime

Written by Liam Kirkaldy on 23 May 2017 in News

Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee writes to Crown Office requesting clarification on admissibility of evidence

MSPs have requested clarification from the Crown Office over the admissibility of evidence in cases of alleged wildlife crime.

The Crown Office faced criticism from RSPB Scotland over its decision to drop a case involving against a gamekeeper accused of setting an illegal trap. The charity released video footage which was due to be used in the trial, but the case was discontinued.

The Crown Office said the video evidence was not admissible because it was filmed for the purposes of gathering evidence.


RELATED CONTENT


Pointing to similar high profile cases, where video evidence of alleged offences was available but not utilised, the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee has written to the Crown Office to request clarification on which pieces of legislation cover the admissibility of evidence, and particularly of video and CCTV evidence, and whether there is guidance which is applied by the Crown Office in reaching a decision.

Convener of the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee Graeme Dey MSP said: “These days, there’s clearly an argument for the use of video, CCTV, or even social media to be considered when a crime against any animal is alleged to have been committed.

“And, as it’s often the case that poaching or killing of wildlife occurs in some of the most remote areas in Scotland, these crimes can sometimes go under the radar because there is no one around to act as a witness.

“In light of recent events, we’ve asked the Crown Office for information on the admissibility of evidence, including video and CCTV, whether there is any clear guidance on this, and how they interpret whether evidence is admissible or not.”

Tags

Categories

Related Articles

High Court orders UK Government to publish its air pollution strategy
28 April 2017

With UK air quality standards in breach of European law, High Courts orders Government forced to publish plans

Bird of prey crimes fall by more than a quarter during 2016
30 March 2017

New statistics show 14 confirmed bird of prey crimes in 2016 compared to 19 the previous year

RSPB Scotland: Wildlife crimes figures represent “the tip of the iceberg”
13 January 2017

The Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform Committee hears that crimes are still going under-recorded

Share this page