Holyrood


Holyrood Daily

Holyrood Daily

Click here for the Holyrood Daily Twitter

Scottish Labour have accused First Minister Alex Salmond of going “absolutely crazy” after he declined to condemn comments made by SNP MSP Bill Walker that compared anti-homophobia campaigners to Nazis.

Following a joint visit by Salmond and Walker to the newly opened Carnegie Primary School in Dunfermline today, Labour say local MP Thomas Docherty asked the First Minister to distance himself from Walker’s comments, and handed him a letter on the matter. Walker has been at the centre of a row regarding gay marriage, recently saying: “anything that puts homosexual relationships as any way equal to male-female marriages is just not right” and pledging to support a parliamentary motion stating no-one should be forced to approve of same-sex marriage. Walker caused further controversy by later saying an anti-homophobia logo reminded him of “the pre-war Nazi-type stuff banning things.”

According to Docherty, once challenged Salmond went “absolutely crazy” and refused to apologise. “He shouted ‘we're in a school’ but we were in a room well away from the pupils and teachers, and Bill Walker was present as well,” said Docherty.

“The First Minister was asking ‘How long have you been an MP son?’ and his minder moved as if to step in between us. Most people think what Bill Walker said was absolutely disgusting and quite frankly if the First Minister doesn’t have the courage to speak out against it then he is more rattled than we all thought.

“Mr Salmond has had weeks to condemn these unacceptable comments, but he keeps refusing. When does he think the right time to apologise is?”

According to the Dunfermline Press, following the disagreement, Salmond told assembled reporters: “I think (Docherty’s) only been an MP for a year or so and he'll learn as time goes on that there's a time and a place for everything and you don't bring politics into a school, that's just daft.
“However, it certainly didn't mar the day. I think it's a reflection of his inexperience.”


Full text of Docherty’s letter to Salmond: 

Dear Mr Salmond

Today when you visit West Fife I would urge you to break your silence on the despicable and disgusting comments of your MSP Bill Walker. 

You will be aware that Mr Walker’s remarks about homosexual couples and his statement that “anything that puts homosexual relationships as any way equal to male-female marriages is just not right” has been regarded as deeply offensive by thousands of my constituents.  This however is nothing compared to the outrage that your SNP colleague has caused by his statement at the weekend when he compared civil liberties campaigners including Stonewall and the Equality Network to Nazis.

Your continued silence is surprising given your role not just as Mr Walker’s Party Leader but as First Minister.  I would therefore urge you today therefore to firstly condemn without further procrastination the entirety of Mr Walker’s remarks and secondly to state what disciplinary actions the SNP intends to take against him for his Nazi slurs.

I look forward to hearing from in due course.

Yours sincerely

Thomas Docherty MP
 

 

A review of vocational education commissioned by the Scottish Government has backed the development of a more transparent, user-friendly skills system.
 
The review, led by former Skills Development Scotland Chair Willy Roe, calls for a more integrated skills landscape that is better joined-up with other parts of the education system and with the world of work.  
 
“Lack of transparency is an issue that affects the system at many levels and is impeding the achievement of peak performance,” the report, published today, states.
 
The learner should be placed at the centre of this system, Roe argues in the report. To achieve this, he proposes a series of measures including a system of ‘labelling’ for courses and developing a ‘scorecard’ of training providers based on learner outcomes. 
 
The review also calls for greater business involvement in skills and training.   “Employers and the wider community should have more influence over what colleges and other providers offer; there should be a system of quality labelling for all publicly-supported programmes; and this review calls for a new system to enable the performance of all learning providers to be publicly compared in a balanced way,” it states.
 
The funding model should also be simplified, according to the review, moving progressively towards a system of “Personal Development Accounts”, where the funding follows the student. This model would “put the learner in the driving seat and “create greater flexibility and responsiveness in the system.” Going forward the review sets out that funding of training should be the “shared responsibility” of individuals, employers and the public sector, as all three parties benefit from such investment. 
 
The report highlights the potential for disjuncture due to the fact that employment policies - including Jobcentre Plus services - are largely reserved to Westminster, while responsibility for skills is devolved to Holyrood. It calls on the Scottish and UK Governments to “negotiate to achieve a more unified, coherent and devolved employment and skills system for Scotland.”
 
Commenting on the review Skills Minister Alasdair Allan said: “It is vitally important that we do everything we can to support our young people to develop the skills and knowledge they need for the workplace. Willy Roe’s report contains a number of suggestions to put the learner at the centre of the journey and improve the education and training that we offer young people once they have left school.”
 
He added: “Clearly, a co-ordinated view needs to be taken across Government, so we shall consider this report in light of the Christie Commission’s recommendations for improving service delivery and redesign to secure the very best value for the public purse and our wider work to reform post-16 education.
 
“This will help to make sure all young people get the opportunity to take part in the education and training they need to reach their full potential.”

The SNP has hit back over accusations that the party’s leadership has become too close to News International, accusing rival parties of ‘hypocrisy’ and challenging them to be similarly open about their dealings with Rupert Murdoch’s media empire.

Documents released by the Scottish Government yesterday showed that First Minister Alex Salmond met Rupert and James Murdoch on separate occasions in 2011, as well as six other meetings with News International executives; far more than any other media organisation.

The published documents also revealed Salmond had written several times to Rupert Murdoch in recent years to invite the News Corp chief executive to events in both the US and Scotland. Scottish Labour said the disclosure revealed “highly questionable behaviour by Scotland’s First Minister” and a “four-year campaign to seduce Murdoch”, while newspapers highlighted Salmond’s reverential language in phrases such as “as ever I found your views insightful and stimulating”.

Today, however, the SNP has hit back, accusing both the Conservatives and Labour of seeking much closer links with News International. While the SNP’s disclosure of Salmond’s media meetings was preceded by similar releases by David Cameron and Ed Miliband, the publishing of official correspondence is a level of detail yet to be matched by UK parties.

SNP MP Stewart Hosie also hit back at comments made by Scottish Labour leader Iain Gray, in which Gray remarked that the Scottish Sun – an influential Murdoch paper that openly backed the SNP ahead of May’s election – had never supported Labour. Hosie said: “Iain Gray’s remarks are wrong, delusional and hypocritical – Alex Salmond has only met with News International a third the number of times as David Cameron in the past year, and only half the number of times as Iain Gray’s own leader Ed Miliband.  He has got his figures all wrong.

“And he is denying reality in saying that the Sun did not support Labour in Scotland – it backed Labour in every election from 1997 to 2007. The SNP is leading the way with the publication of all correspondence with News International and publication of records stretching back to 2007.

“All other parties must immediately release their correspondence, and the full four years of meetings. At all levels Labour, the Tories and the Lib Dems should release their correspondence, a full list of meetings and match the high standards set by the SNP.”

The SNP has today also released what information is available from previous Freedom of Information requests of meetings between Jack McConnell and News Corporation. You can access the information here and here.
 

First Minister Alex Salmond has met with both Rupert and James Murdoch in 2011, information released by the Scottish Government today shows.

Salmond met Rupert Murdoch, Chief Executive of News Corp, in June, just weeks before the phone-hacking scandal that led to the closure of the News of the World broke.

Apart from his meetings with the Murdochs, Salmond has met with executives from News International, Newscorp’s UK newspaper publishing arm, a further five times since the turn of the year as well as addressing the company’s conference in April in the run-up to the Scottish election.

The release comes at a time when politicians of all parties have sought to distance themselves from News International after the company became the subject of fierce criticism regarding allegations of widespread phone-hacking and illegal activity.

The Scottish Government had been under pressure from opposition parties to release the information after both Prime Minister David Cameron and Ed Miliband made similar details public.

Senior Conservative ministers have come under fire in recent weeks for enjoying close relations with News International, particularly former Chief Executive Rebekah Brooks, who was arrested last month. According to the Scottish Government records, Salmond last met Brooks in 2008.

The disclosures also revealed all correspondence between Salmond and Rupert Murdoch since becoming First Minister. The letters reveal Salmond appeared keen to foster a good relationship with the media mogul, first inviting him to become a member of the GlobalScot network, as well as offering tickets to attend a performance of the play ‘Black Watch’ in New York and the Ryder Cup golf in Kentucky.

Scottish Labour leader Iain Gray said the letters reveal Salmond had orchestrated a “campaign to court Rupert Murdoch” and described the First Minister’s behaviour as “highly questionable”. He added: “What is now clear is Alex Salmond has waged a four-year campaign since he became First Minister, to seduce Rupert Murdoch and News International, which has included gifts.

 “It has been a top priority and he has spent more of his media time in the last year with News International than any other party leader in Britain.  

 “Now it is clear why Alex Salmond has been so reticent about criticising News International during the phone-hacking scandal and reluctant to publish details of his meetings with them.

“He has met them more than any other media group and this relationship has been growing ever closer over time, culminating in the Murdoch press’s backing for SNP in the Scottish elections.

Since the escalation of the phone-hacking scandal last month a wide range of public figures have denounced a culture in which politicians were cowed by influential News International papers such as the Sun and the Sunday Times. In the weeks running up to the SNP’s landslide victory in May, the Scottish Sun publicly endorsed the party with a headline reading: ‘Play It Again Salm’.

The list further showed that in the past year Salmond has held meetings with an eclectic mix of senior journalists from all of Scotland’s major newspapers and broadcasters, including the editor of Holyrood magazine for several interviews.

The full list of Salmond’s meeting with media executives can be accessed here.

A similar list for Scottish Ministers is available here

The principal of the University of Abertay Dundee has retired, following a protracted employment dispute with the university’s senior management.
 
The announcement by the university comes after principal Professor Bernard King’s suspension in January. The move was thought to have been related to a disagreement between King - the longest serving vice chancellor in the UK - and Abertay’s governing body over the institution’s long-term plan.  The 65-year-old claimed he was facing age discrimination and had lodged papers with an employment tribunal.
 
The highly contentious dispute saw a number of resignations from the university court. One of the public figures to step down, businessman Derek Douglas, had called for an independent inquiry into King’s suspension. 
 
However, the university has today released a statement confirming King’s retirement and stating that all legal claims between the university and the former principal have been resolved. 
 
The statement pays tribute to the former vice-chancellor for his "unique" contribution to the university over the last 19 years. Amongst his achievements for Abertay it lists welding, “a small Scottish university into a globally recognised centre of excellence in information technology, computer games, the creative media industries, mathematical modelling and visualisation of complex systems for environmental prediction and systems pathology enabling predictive treatments of certain cancers” and developing it to become the UK’s first National Centre of Excellence in computer gaming education and the UK hub for prototyping for the computer games industry.  The University Court has renamed the library the Bernard King Library, “in recognition of its critical role in the creation of Dundee's Digital University”.     
 
The full statement reads as follows:
 
The University of Abertay Dundee wishes to confirm the retirement of its Principal and Vice-Chancellor, Professor Bernard King CBE. The University is pleased to announce that all legal claims between the University and Professor King have been withdrawn and all outstanding issues between the two parties have been resolved. The University wishes to recognise Professor King's unique contribution to its development and success over his 19 years stewardship. 
 
Professor King has been an outstanding Vice-Chancellor and Principal. He has welded a small Scottish university into a globally recognised centre of excellence in information technology, computer games, the creative media industries, mathematical modelling and visualisation of complex systems for environmental prediction and systems pathology enabling predictive treatments of certain cancers. In that context, Professor King has created Abertay as the UK's first National Centre of Excellence in computer gaming education and the UK hub for prototyping for the computer games industry. He has achieved national and international recognition for the University through receipt of the first BAFTA Ones to Watch award, created to encourage and reward innovation from emerging games designers and awarded annually to the winners of Abertay's innovative international computer games design competition, Dare to be Digital. Professor King has been a leader in the Scottish and UK Governments' desire to encourage ingenuity and brilliance and to capitalise on the knowledge transfer required for the development of the national economy.
 
In so doing, he has also created an institution which encompasses a wide range of disciplines including environmental science, business development including oil and gas, social and health sciences and contemporary sciences.
 
Professor King has been the UK's longest serving Principal and Vice-Chancellor and was instrumental in leading the transition of the Dundee Institute of Technology to university status. The University took justifiable pride in his election as Vice-Convenor and Convenor of Universities Scotland for the past five years, his Vice-Presidency of Universities UK and his election UK - wide to the Board of that organisation. Professor King also served on the Boards of Scottish Enterprise Tayside, Tayside Primary Healthcare Trust, the Scottish Crops Research Institute, including five years as Chair, the Higher Education Academy, including chairing its Audit Committee, the Scottish Leadership  Foundation, the University and Colleges Admissions Service, the Council of the Association of Commonwealth Universities,  the executive of higher education think tank Million+, the Council for Industry and Higher Education and many others.  He retains his Governorship of the "Unicorn" Preservation Society here in Dundee.
 
During his tenure, Professor King encouraged the transformation of the student experience through the creation of "White Space" - a multi-disciplinary learning environment to stimulate creative thinking and research. A new library, student centre, student village and the transformation of the Kydd Building to a studio based multidisciplinary environment testify to his vision for and determination to create, a physical environment attuned to needs of a university of the future.
 
Nor have his achievements been limited to the university's standing within Scotland. Developing Abertay's international reach has long been a priority. By building relationships with universities overseas including partnerships with Peking and Shanghai, two of China's leading universities, as well as universities in India, Malaysia, Singapore, Egypt, Turkey, Nigeria, Canada and the United States of America, Professor King has ensured Abertay's place on the world map. He is particularly proud that for many years Abertay was used as the model to study leadership and management of change by Vice-Chancellors of sub-Saharan African universities and that the Africa Union submission to the G8 at Gleneagles on higher education was prepared by a pan-African delegation working at Abertay.
 
Professor King leaves behind a university in good shape, attracting record numbers of student applications and well prepared for the inevitable challenges ahead. The University and Professor King are united in a joint desire to move forward in the interests of Abertay’s students and staff and to build on past successes, to the benefit of the city of Dundee and the wider community. The University wishes Professor King, who retires with the title of Emeritus Professor, all the best in his future endeavours.
 
As a tribute to Professor King's achievements, the Court of the University of Abertay Dundee is pleased to name the library the Bernard King Library in recognition of its critical role in the creation of Dundee's Digital University.
 


newsletters_without_border
The Scottish Parliament's Local Government and Regeneration Committee is broadly supportive of the campaign for a living wage. A report published today by the committee recognises the complex range of factors,...
Good morning - here are the top 10 stories in Scotland this morning: Independent Scotland would be laden with debt, warns NIESR (Daily Telegraph) Ex-adviser condemns SNP 'spin' in official documents (Scotsman) Youth...
Welcome to First Minister's Questions: [liveblog]...
Good morning - here are the top 10 stories in Scotland this morning: Independent Scotland to stick with sterling (Scotsman) SNP criticised over plans to keep sterling (Press & Journal) Scottish independence: Peer's...
Good morning - here are the top 10 stories in Scotland this morning: Former RBS boss Fred Goodwin stripped of knighthood (STV News) Fred Goodwin knighthood 'hysteria' criticised (BBC Scotland) Drive to find...
 

Holyrood opinion poll
Do you feel negotiations over the terms of the independence referendum will...
 
"Holyrood magazine is the talk of the parliamentary steamie, providing real insight into the business of good government and legislation in Scotland. It is indispensable reading for all who need to know about the policies and politics of Scotland's democracy."
Alex Salmond
The Rt Hon Alex Salmond MSP
First Minister
"I hate doing interviews with people and saying 'Oh, I really like your paper...', but what I like about Holyrood magazine is that you take that good old fashioned journalist approach and tell the reader what is happening and what is going on in a factual way, and the interviews that you do give a really deep flavour of the person behind the politics."
Alastair Campbell
Alastair Campbell
Labour's king of spin
Holyrood magazine | Holyrood magazine conferences | T&Cs for delegates | T&Cs for sponsors and exhibitors | T&Cs for advertisers | T&Cs for subscribers