In its Stage 1 report published today the committee endorses the general principles of the bill, which aims to modernise Scotland’s public health legislation, but also makes a series of recommendations about how the proposals could be improved to ensure the correct balance between public health priorities and the rights of individuals. 

As part of this the committee calls for the bill to include a right of appeal against compulsory medical examination, in light of the bill’s current proposals which would mean an individual could be medically examined, quarantined or detained in hospital if they are suspected of having an infectious disease or where there is a significant risk to public health. 

Committee convener, Christine Grahame MSP, said: 

"We live in times where people travel more - and to more places - than ever before. Against that background and in the light of outbreaks such as E coli at home and SARS around the globe, this bill will put Scotland's house in order. The committee views these provisions as necessary, given the context of global biosecurity and international co-operation." 

Deputy committee convener and Liberal Democrat Shadow Health Secretary Ross Finnie MSP also urged the government to bring forward the amendments as soon as possible.

 “The Committee agreed that a substantial amount of technical amendments are necessary to ensure that this is an effective instrument and consonant with Scots Law.

“I urge the Government to bring forward the amendments as soon as Stage 1 is completed, so that the principles of the Bill can be given proper effect.

“When amended, the Public Health Bill will be a welcome measure, which updates existing legislation and makes public health provisions fit for the 21st century.”

The committee’s report can be accessed here