Holyrood


Articles by Jim Sillars
Subscribe to RSS feed

A better way

If there is a case for remaining in the Union, a hard-headed case based on economics and judgement about the future, it certainly hasn’t been made by those Westminster Tories, led by Cameron, trying the ‘British patriot’ game on us. Of course there is a British dimension in almost every Scot. There are relatives scattered all over England, there are cultural interests in common, sporting interests, old military connections. I am ex-Royal Navy, and still have a lingering affection for that very British institution and its white ensign, despite Nelson’s signal at Trafalgar, and owe it a great deal in respect of my personal development.

But these are in the realm of sentiment.

Sentiment does not a breakfast produce for any Scottish family. If, as Cameron would wish, Scots vote in the referendum with their hearts rather than their heads, then the nation will cut its economic throat – there is nothing ahead as part of the United Kingdom except going downwards, permanent heavy unemployment, and cuts, cuts, cuts that will rend our social fabric.

Here’s a sobering fact. The Budget cut another £10bn from public expenditure. For every £10 of cuts the Treasury aims to impose, we have only suffered one so far. There are a further nine to go. As Nick Brown the Labour MP pointed out in the Budget debate, as well as the additional £10bn cuts in this Budget, there will be an additional £8bn in 2015-16, and another additional £15bn in 2016-17.

The way unionists talk about the benefits of being part of a big G20 country, you would think we were living in a successful paradise. The brutal reality is that Osborne will have to borrow at least £120bn this comin...

Continue reading...

Posted in Comment, Jim Sillars | 9 Comments

Taken for a ride

They were wetting their pants with excitement in Downing Street and the Foreign Office when it was announced that David Cameron would fly on Air Force One during his recent visit to the United States. The usually staid Daily Telegraph was, if not excited, impressed: “The fact that Mr Cameron will be the first foreign leader to be given a ride aboard Air Force One suggests more than the normal courtesies are in place.” Gee-whizz, jings crivvens, Merkel, Sarkozy, those preening Eurocrats styling themselves as Presidents, they never had a ride on the big jet as a prize, a signal sign of presidential approval, for being such good chaps as the Brits have proved in support of American policy – you name it, any policy. I find it hard to [...]



Posted in Comment, Jim Sillars | Comments Off

Dancing around devolution

It’s time the SNP membership woke up to smell the coffee. In case they haven’t noticed, the objective that gave it life and has sustained it over many difficult, barren years is being undermined by its own leadership courting an alternative which, at root, seeks a vote for Scotland to remain within the United Kingdom. Devo-max, devo-plus, devo-anything is a vote against independence. It is not an accident that these various ill-defined models have been punted ever more vigorously as the debate about independence has started to get under way. “Anything but independence” is their true meaning. There is a dishonesty at the heart of these proposals. Every one of them would keep Scotland anchored within the UK, and they can only be implemented by the government at Westminster which, [...]



Posted in Features, Inside Track | Comments Off

The science bit

There was an orgy of self-congratulation at Holyrood, Thursday 1 March. Each MSP was telling the others how virtuous they were, how deeply concerned they were about the fate awaiting the poor of this world, and how this small nation of five million people is making a great contribution to saving them. It was one of those green global warming days when grown men and women take leave of their senses, and swallow any piece of propaganda aimed at them by the vested NGO interests who, without us being scared to death, would be out of funds. While more and more scientists are writing to demolish the allegation that humans are in charge of the planet’s climate, and the Inter Governmental Panel on Climate Change has been exposed as the [...]



Posted in Comment, Jim Sillars | 2 Comments

More please, sir

So, the high and mighty Prime Minister of the United Kingdom comes to Scotland, treats us like an Oliver Twist, onto whose devolution plate he might, only might, mind you, dollop additional powers – but only if we do his bidding and reject independence. Am I the only Scot who thinks it insulting to be told, “be a good boy, do what I tell you, and you might get a sweetie”? The Cameron ploy, which some older journalists have pointed out, is not new. Sir Alec Douglas Home played the ‘we’ll give you more powers’ game in the 1979 referendum and helped sink the proposed Scottish Assembly. He was, of course, vague about what those better powers would be, but nevertheless too many Scots fell for it, and we failed [...]



Posted in Comment, Jim Sillars | 1 Comment




newsletters_without_border
[caption id="flickrImage_1" align="alignleft" width="200" caption="Nicola Sturgeon MSP by theSNP"][/caption] Scotland is increasingly seen as a world leader in telehealth and telecare, Health Secretary Nicola Sturgeon said today, but added that...
The Scottish Government will consider whether pupils across Scotland would benefit from having access to portable technology like the iPad in class, based on the experience of a number of...
Good morning - here are the top 10 stories in Scotland this morning: Cameron 'not fussy' about timing of vote (Press & Journal) Benefit reforms paint 'bleak picture' for Scotland's most vulnerable...
It was a job that might not have existed, but today the University of Abertay Dundee has announced that Professor Nigel Seaton will be its new Principal and Vice-Chancellor. Professor Seaton,...
Scotland is one of the leaders in telehealth in Europe but we need to maintain that momentum, Professor George Crooks, director of the Scottish Centre for Telehealth and Telecare has...
 

Holyrood opinion poll
Do you feel negotiations over the terms of the independence referendum will...
 
"Holyrood magazine is the talk of the parliamentary steamie, providing real insight into the business of good government and legislation in Scotland. It is indispensable reading for all who need to know about the policies and politics of Scotland's democracy."
Alex Salmond
The Rt Hon Alex Salmond MSP
First Minister
"I hate doing interviews with people and saying 'Oh, I really like your paper...', but what I like about Holyrood magazine is that you take that good old fashioned journalist approach and tell the reader what is happening and what is going on in a factual way, and the interviews that you do give a really deep flavour of the person behind the politics."
Alastair Campbell
Alastair Campbell
Labour's king of spin
 
Holyrood magazine | Holyrood magazine conferences | Terms and conditions for delegates | Terms and conditions for sponsors and exhibitors